Client Testimonials

Merchant Circle Reviews

Easy Shopping Experience

I went into Donald’s shop with no idea of what to look for or what to even dream about. I gave him a few ideas as to what was whispered into my ear here and there. He searched for the perfect ring for me and helped create the perfect ring at the perfect price. He is a true and honest business man. He is also very friendly which helps lighten your mood while you are shopping, especially if you go in with no idea as to what you want or need. He can also contact you via email so that someone special has no idea you are even looking. OVERALL: GREAT GUY, GREAT BUSINESS MAN, HONEST, and FAIR. highly recommend seeing Mr. Donald Duffy.


Amazing Engagement Experience!

I have been a client of Donald Duffy, owner of the Diamond Loft, for over 20 years. In December, 2011, Donald created the most amazing engagement ring for me — an exquisite cushion cut diamond in a white gold setting with side stones. It took my breath away! Not to mention Donald is great to do business with. His prices are fair (much better than “the diamond district” in downtown Pittsburgh) and he is an honest and ethical busines man. I recommend him highly and will continue as a client of the Diamond Loft for many years to come!

Shelley S.

Exceptional Service and Experience

Several months ago I had the privilege of working with Donald Duffy as I looked for the perfect diamond engagement ring. My parents have been clients of Donald’s for many years, and from the beauty and quality of my mother’s jewelry I was confident that I would be in great hands with Don. From the perspective of a young man who had never looked at diamonds in close detail, Don was extremely helpful in teaching me the ins and outs of what differentiates one diamond from the next. I went to the Diamond Loft with a basic concept in mind, and left with an absolutely stunning engagement ring at a price that I was very happy with. I have complete and total trust in Don as a businessman and friend, and I will no doubt be a customer for many years to come (my fiancee is really looking forward to it!!).


Just like the sign says INTERNET PRICES

We were shopping for a diamond engagement ring at five different stores and saw this is sign in the front window INTERNET PRICES – ENGAGEMENT RINGS and went in . The owner, Don, explained to us that he carried only certified diamonds mostly GIA. None had any yellow, cracks , or carbon spots in them.His supplier brings them back from Belgium every three weeks and purchases about 3.2 million dollars. The best time for picking these diamonds is when they arrive. We liked this guy he was straight forward talking, no sales pressure and the rings had a great warranty any repairs or adjustments are done the same day. We highly recommend this store for any jewelry purchase.

Beth and Josh

Best in the business!!

Owner is friendly and gracious. Will absolutely provide you the best value for your price range. And as a result of his committment to providing the best service and best product at the best price, his clients are loyal and continue patronizing him. After 15 years, I would not consider buying my jewelery anywhere else or make a major jewelery purchase without his advice. Absolutely the best in the business!!


Gorgeous quality jewelry for the best price and sold with honesty!

We found Donald 12 years ago and have been loyal customers ever since. Our first purchase was a beautiful pair of diamond stud earrings that I recently upgraded. Donald makes it easy to make repeat purchases with him by offering simple upgrades of diamonds previously purchased from him. I just called ahead, walked in with my earrings and 10 minutes later walked out with bigger diamond earrings….what could be better than that! We also purchased my gorgeous custom engagement ring from Donald. He followed this with a custom wedding band that he made by melting the gold from my parents wedding bands and adding some of his stunning diamonds to really make it sparkle. Donald made the wedding band curves to exactly match that of my engagement ring. After 10 years of an engagement and marriage I still get comments about how beautiful my wedding set is and how much it sparkles! Donald is well worth our 2 hour trip from OH and we won’t shop for diamonds and gold anywhere else!


Customer Referral Rewards

Earn $50 for referring customers to My Diamond Jewelry Store! Click here for more information.
Subscribe to our mailing list
* indicates required